

Read my thoughts on if shipped cookies live up to the Crumbl hype in my detailed post. Of course, the Pink Chilled Sugar Cookie was also a weekly standard until just recently too (now that flavor has moved to the rotating menu).Īs far as the rotating flavors go (there’s four or five each week), I’ve seen a lot of buzz around Birthday Cake, Cornbread, Key Lime Pie, and anything with Oreo! Oreo, chocolate, or peanut butter base cookies are my personal pick any day, yummm.ĭid you know? Crumbl Cookies ships cookies too. The most popular cookie at Crumbl as far as volume sold is probably the Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie since it is available every week. While I haven’t come across any cold hard statistics from Crumbl, I’ve seen the excitement all over social media for various flavors and there are certainly favorites! What are the most popular Crumbl Cookies flavors? Love Crumbl? Here’s some tips on how to snag free Crumbl Cookies. Note that as of April 2022, Crumbl discontinued the weekly offering of their Classic Pink Sugar Cookie (even more reason to make copycat cookies!), but recently brought it back in September 2022 as a slightly modified vanilla sugar cookie with pink almond icing (real almond extract). Milk Chocolate Chip (every week): a chewy chocolate chip cookie with giant chocolate chips.Classic Pink Sugar (every week): a chilled vanilla sugar cookie with pink almond icing.Buckeye Brownie: A chocolate brownie cookie with layers of peanut butter topping and melted semi-sweet chocolate on top.Cookie Butter White Chip: A served-warm cookie butter cookie with cookie butter pieces and white chips.Chocolate Pumpkin Cheesecake: A dark chocolate cookie filled with cookies & cream pieces topped with pumpkin spice cheesecake frosting and cookies & cream crumbs.Strawberry Cake: A warm strawberry-and-vanilla cookie topped with strawberry cream cheese frosting and white chocolate curls.
